Best Practices

Historical Thinking

Scholars, students, and teachers model historical thinking.

Showing 70 of 70 results

Piscataway Park and Tobacco Farming

Piscataway Park and Tobacco Farming

In 1700s Maryland and Virginia, farmers lived and died by the quality of their tobacco. Teachers tour Maryland’s Piscataway Park, learning about farmers’ …

Touring Monticello

Touring Monticello

Tour Monticello with TAH teachers and learn about the history behind Thomas Jefferson’s home.

A Close Look at the Ulysses S. Grant Memorial

A Close Look at the Ulysses S. Grant Memorial

Historian Christopher Hamner engages educators in close questioning of the Ulysses S. Grant Memorial in Washington, DC.

Monticello: Jefferson's Experiment

Monticello: Jefferson's Experiment

TAH teachers get an introduction to Monticello as Thomas Jefferson’s ’laboratory.'

Pockets from the Past: Daily Life at Monticello

Pockets from the Past: Daily Life at Monticello

What do the contents of pockets say about their owners? TAH teachers model strategies for examining and questioning artifacts.

Smithsonian American Art Museum: "Acehlous and Hercules"

Smithsonian American Art Museum: "Acehlous and Hercules"

Analyzing a massive primary source? Divide it up! Teachers at the Smithsonian American Art Museum examine a Thomas Hart Benton mural.

Smithsonian American Art Museum: Teaching with 19th-Century Art

Smithsonian American Art Museum: Teaching with 19th-Century Art

Watch Suzannah Niepold of the Smithsonian American Art Museum guide teachers in analyzing four works of art.

Ford's Theatre: Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address

Ford's Theatre: Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address

Ford’s Theatre Society’s Sarah Jencks leads teachers through Abraham Lincoln’s Second Inaugural Address and follow-up activities, in this example of on-site TAH …

Smithsonian American Art Museum: "Inventing a Better Mousetrap"

Smithsonian American Art Museum: "Inventing a Better Mousetrap"

Take a look at artifacts from the past—what might they be? Teachers model questioning objects in this Smithsonian exhibit on inventions.

Reading Place with the National Building Museum

Reading Place with the National Building Museum

What does architecture say about the past and the present? TAH teachers learn strategies for close examination of buildings in Washington, DC.

Visiting the George Mason Memorial

Visiting the George Mason Memorial

How can you get teachers thinking about monuments and memorials as secondary and primary sources? Historians Christopher Hamner and Michael O’Malley started out …

Smithsonian American Art Museum: "Westward the Course of Empire"

Smithsonian American Art Museum: "Westward the Course of Empire"

Watch Suzannah Niepold guide TAH teachers through analyzing the differences between two versions of Emanuel Gottlieb Leutze’s Westward the Course of Empire …

National Portrait Gallery: Teaching with 19th-Century Portraits

National Portrait Gallery: Teaching with 19th-Century Portraits

Watch Briana Zavadil White introduce teachers to portraits of inventors and presidents from the 19th century.

Slave Life at Mount Vernon

Slave Life at Mount Vernon

How do the buildings and artifacts at Mount Vernon reflect the lives of the people who lived and worked there? Educators explore the slave quarters and question …

Slavery at Jefferson's Monticello: Paradox of Liberty

Slavery at Jefferson's Monticello: Paradox of Liberty

Educators tour the NMAAHC exhibit “Slavery at Jefferson’s Monticello: Paradox of Liberty” and ask about approaches to presenting the lives of Thomas Jefferson …

A Close Look at the World War II Memorial

A Close Look at the World War II Memorial

Historian Christopher Hamner introduces educators to the World War II Memorial in Washington, DC. He asks, what was its intended audience and purpose?

A Close Look at the FDR Memorial

A Close Look at the FDR Memorial

Historian Christopher Hamner visits the original Franklin D. Roosevelt Memorial with educators. They consider the different purposes the old and new memorials …

The U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum: Personalizing History

The U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum: Personalizing History

Make large-scale historic events like the Holocaust personal with artifacts and stories from individual human lives.

Smithsonian American Art Museum: Close Observation

Smithsonian American Art Museum: Close Observation

Close observation and an inquisitive mind are all the tools you need to start analyzing primary sources! Teachers model analyzing works of art.

Paintings About Segregation

Paintings About Segregation

Textbooks describe segregation in a few pages, but these artists share complicated, personal views of how segregation looked and felt.

Women's Rights: Sarah Bagley Letters

Women's Rights: Sarah Bagley Letters

What do these letters from a women’s rights activist reveal about social causes in the 1840s?

Women's Suffrage: Jane Addams's Article

Women's Suffrage: Jane Addams's Article

Who was Jane Addams, and how is her article “Why Women Should Vote” still relevant today?

Women's Suffrage: Burroughs's Article

Women's Suffrage: Burroughs's Article

In the struggle for women’s suffrage, how did African American women represent themselves? TJ Boisseau reads an article by activist Nannie Helen Burroughs.

Women's Suffrage Photographs

Women's Suffrage Photographs

How did the women’s suffrage movement use the rise of journalism to its advantage? TJ Boisseau looks at what photographs reveal.

Women's Suffrage Cartoon

Women's Suffrage Cartoon

How does a political cartoon use popular beliefs about women to make its point? Historian TJ Boisseau examines the conventions in this image.

World War II Memorial

World War II Memorial

What meanings does the World War II Memorial in Washington, DC, have? Historians Christopher Hamner and Michael O’Malley try to answer this question.

Ulysses S. Grant Memorial

Ulysses S. Grant Memorial

How does the Ulysses S. Grant Memorial in Washington, DC, depict Grant and the Civil War? Historians Christopher Hamner and Michael O’Malley take a look.

Jackie Robinson and Martin Luther King Jr.

Jackie Robinson and Martin Luther King Jr.

What connections do documents related to the Jackie Robinson Testimonial Dinner in 1962 make between these two men?

Letters from the Philippines

Letters from the Philippines

Letters from U.S. soldiers during the Philippine-American War reveal perspectives very different from the official language of liberation.

Scenes in the Life of Harriet Tubman

Scenes in the Life of Harriet Tubman

Can you trust a biography? Historian Tiya Miles analyzes an 1869 biography of abolitionist Harriet Tubman.

Abolitionist Speeches by African American Women

Abolitionist Speeches by African American Women

How do the speeches of Sojourner Truth and Frances Ellen Watkins Harper differ? Historian Carla Peterson examines documents for answers.

The Iran Hostage Crisis: Diary of Robert Ode

The Iran Hostage Crisis: Diary of Robert Ode

Diaries give a personal view of historical events. Historian Peter Hahn interprets the diary of Robert Ode, kept as he was held hostage in Iran.

Japanese American Internment: Executive Order 9066

Japanese American Internment: Executive Order 9066

How did the World War II internment of Japanese Americans happen? Historian Frank Wu examines Executive Order 9066.

Japanese American Internment: Ansel Adams Photos

Japanese American Internment: Ansel Adams Photos

If the U.S. interned you and your family, how would you respond?

1775 Colonial Newspaper Article

1775 Colonial Newspaper Article

Smithsonian Barbara Clark Smith looks at what a colonial newspaper article says—and doesn’t say—about a Patriot protest.

1804 Inventory

1804 Inventory

What can an inventory tell you about daily life in Delaware in 1804? Curator Barbara Clark Smith asks this document four questions.

Herman Melville's "Bartleby, the Scrivener"

Herman Melville's "Bartleby, the Scrivener"

Is reading a piece of historic literature once enough? Not if you want to get the most out of literary sources.

1853 Daguerreotype

1853 Daguerreotype

What does an 1853 daguerreotype have to say? Plenty, says Frank Goodyear, particularly about tourist culture and the rise of railroads and photography.

Two Blues Songs

Two Blues Songs

Written primary sources only tell you so much. To learn about history that was never written down, listen to sources like these two songs.

Thomas Nast Cartoon

Thomas Nast Cartoon

Today, we accept paper—and electronic—money as a fact of life. Historian Michael O’Malley analyzes an 1876 cartoon criticizing “greenbacks.”

FDR's Second Inaugural Address

FDR's Second Inaugural Address

What is the key line in Franklin D. Roosevelt’s second inaugural address? Historian David Kennedy gives his answer.

The Election of 1932: Photographs of FDR

The Election of 1932: Photographs of FDR

What can a photograph of Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932 reveal? Donald A. Ritchie looks at the people captured in this photograph.

The Election of 1932: Clifford Berryman Cartoon

The Election of 1932: Clifford Berryman Cartoon

Donald A. Ritchie, Historian of the U.S. Senate, asks how a political cartoon captures a moment of change in the 1932 presidential campaign.

Massive Resistance Political Cartoons

Massive Resistance Political Cartoons

Watch J. Douglas Smith discuss the Massive Resistance policy enacted by U.S. Senator, Harry F. Byrd, Sr., in 1956.

John Smith Map

John Smith Map

Watch Smithsonian curator Barbara Clark Smith discuss John Smith’s Map of Virginia published in London in 1612.

John Brown's Body

John Brown's Body

Chandra Manning discusses the song “John Brown’s Body,” and how music can be an important source in discovering the past.

Declaration of Independence

Declaration of Independence

Historian Rosemarie Zagarri reads the Declaration of Independence closely, taking time to define its context and its effects.

Civil War Letters

Civil War Letters

Historian Chandra Manning analyzes Civil War letters from black and white Union soldiers and a Confederate soldier.

Bill of Rights

Bill of Rights

Whitman Ridgway outlines some of the context in which the Bill of Rights was created and arguments surrounding its creation.

The Salem Witch Trials

The Salem Witch Trials

Absolving the guilty and punishing the innocent. Historian Elizabeth Reis looks at primary sources recording testimony in witchcraft trials.

Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address

Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address

Teaching the Reconstruction? Ford’s Theatre’s Sarah Jencks leads teachers through Abraham Lincoln’s Second Inaugural Address and follow-up activities.

The Barbary Pirates: Letter from Tripoli

The Barbary Pirates: Letter from Tripoli

Two letters from 1800 Tripoli lead into a story of piracy, privateering, slavery, international politics, and war at sea and on land.

FDR's Fireside Chats

FDR's Fireside Chats

Historian Allida Black analyzes FDR’s April 28, 1935 Fireside Chat. What ideas and arguments does FDR present to the American people?

My Lai Massacre Political Cartoon

My Lai Massacre Political Cartoon

Professor Meredith Lair examines a 1971 political cartoon and what it says about U.S. reaction to the My Lai Massacre and the trial of Lt. Willam Calley.

Cross-checking Sources and Testing Hypotheses

Cross-checking Sources and Testing Hypotheses

Challenge students to gather evidence from multiple primary sources. Here, a high school student uses two related primary sources to understand the civil rights …

Reading for Context

Reading for Context

If students lack historical context, they can miss the substance of a reading. Watch a high school sophomore use what he knows about the 1950s and 1960s to …

Close Reading for Vocabulary, Context, and Tone

Close Reading for Vocabulary, Context, and Tone

Analyzing a source requires context for a more complete understanding.

Primary Sources as Windows into the Past

Primary Sources as Windows into the Past

Excite students by introducing them to primary sources that answer questions they have—not just questions you pose to them.

Slave Receipts

Slave Receipts

What do slave receipts reveal? Ever considered using similar documents to teach?

Frederick Douglass's Autobiographies

Frederick Douglass's Autobiographies

Use autobiographies to deconstruct views of slavery and historical heroes.

Narratives of Slavery

Narratives of Slavery

One institution, two very different perspectives. An expert contrasts records.

Daily Objects, 19th-century America

Daily Objects, 19th-century America

With the advent of industry and western expansion, U.S. businesses mass produced dreams of affluence and progress.

Jefferson's Confidential Letter to Congress

Jefferson's Confidential Letter to Congress

Jefferson, surprised by the Louisiana Purchase? Maybe not. Historian Leah Glaser looks at a letter from Jefferson requesting funding for the Corps of Discovery.

Cherokee Law of Blood

Cherokee Law of Blood

A Cherokee Nation Supreme Court document reveals the fluidity of racial identity.

Creative Memo on Lay's Products

Creative Memo on Lay's Products

Potato chip marketing—how a luxury item became an everyday U.S. food.

Intertextual Reading of Two Primary Documents

Intertextual Reading of Two Primary Documents

A student demonstrates thinking aloud reading two documents.

Close Reading of a Primary Document

Close Reading of a Primary Document

On the website Historical Thinking Matters, a student reads aloud a speech by former Louisiana Governor Huey Long.

Seeing (and Engaging in) Historical Thinking: A Tutorial

Seeing (and Engaging in) Historical Thinking: A Tutorial

This interactive tutorial models a four-step process for analyzing historical sources.

Sourcing a Primary Document

Sourcing a Primary Document

See sourcing in action, as a historian reads a document about the Scopes Trial.

An Introduction to Historical Thinking and Reading

An Introduction to Historical Thinking and Reading

Watch this flash movie for a peek at how historians read and question sources.

Quick Links →